OnSurvey · Leadership feedback

Why Manager Effectiveness Surveys Reveal What Performance Reviews Never Will

Performance reviews tell you whether targets were hit. Engagement surveys tell you whether people are happy. Neither tells you whether your managers are any good at managing. That is the gap manager effectiveness surveys close.

This post covers why they matter, the five moments when the feedback matters most, the myths that stop organizations running them, and a four-step implementation in Workday with OnSurvey: design, triggers, monitoring and secure sharing.

How do we identify the future leaders?

Think about your highest-performing individual contributor who just got promoted to a management role. They were brilliant at execution. But are they brilliant at coaching? At giving feedback that actually changes behavior? At creating psychological safety in a room?

Manager effectiveness surveys aren’t just about evaluating current managers. They’re one of the most powerful — and most underused — tools for identifying your next generation of leaders.

Consider this: when you ask a team how their manager handles conflict, communicates priorities, or supports professional growth, you’re not just getting a report card. You’re getting a leadership signal. You’re learning who naturally elevates the people around them — and who, despite good intentions, might be holding a team back.

The question isn’t whether leadership matters. It’s whether your organization has a system for seeing it clearly.

When does this feedback actually matter? More often than you think

It’s easy to treat manager effectiveness as a once-a-year ritual. But the scenarios where this feedback becomes critical are far more frequent.

The new manager transition

Someone steps into a leadership role for the first time. They're eager, probably anxious, and almost certainly replicating whatever management style they experienced — good or bad. Without structured feedback in the first 90 to 180 days, bad habits calcify.

The reorganization

Teams are restructured. Reporting lines change. A manager who thrived with a team of five senior engineers may struggle with a blended team of twelve across multiple time zones. The context changed, but did anyone check whether the leadership approach changed with it?

The retention crisis no one can explain

A team is losing people. Exit interviews point to "better opportunities elsewhere." But is that the whole story? Often, the pattern underneath is a manager who isn't providing growth, recognition, or clarity.

The high-performer plateau

A team consistently hits targets but never exceeds them. Innovation is low. People seem fine but not energized.

The M&A integration

Two companies merge. Each has different management cultures, expectations, and norms.

Let’s talk about the myths

Manager effectiveness surveys carry more organizational baggage than almost any other people practice. Some of the most persistent myths deserve to be named directly.

Engagement surveys measure the temperature of the room. Manager effectiveness surveys examine the thermostat.

This fear is understandable — and it’s exactly why design matters so much.

They won’t be — if they don’t trust the process. And trust is earned through demonstrated action, not through a banner on the survey that says “your responses are confidential.”

In too many organizations, that’s exactly what it is. The survey goes out because it’s on the annual calendar.

If you have managers, you need feedback on how they’re managing. Size and stage change the implementation — not the principle.

Implementing manager effectiveness surveys in Workday using OnSurvey

Theory is important. But at some point, you need to build the system. Here’s how to implement a manager effectiveness survey program in Workday using OnSurvey.

Step 1: Design your survey using the OnSurvey designer

The quality of your insights depends entirely on the quality of your questions. OnSurvey’s survey designer lets you build instruments that balance structure with openness.

Designing questions that request specific feedback

Start with behavioral, situation-specific questions rather than abstract ratings. For example:

  • “When you bring a problem to your manager, how effectively do they help you think through solutions rather than simply directing you?” (Scale: 1–5 with behavioral anchors)
  • “In the last 30 days, has your manager provided feedback that helped you improve a specific skill or behavior?” (Yes / No / Not applicable)
  • “How well does your manager communicate the reasoning behind team decisions?” (Scale: 1–5 with behavioral anchors)

Including open-ended questions

Structured questions show you patterns. Open-ended questions show you stories. Include two to three open-response prompts:

  • “What is one thing your manager does that makes a real difference to your day-to-day experience?”
  • “If you could change one thing about how your manager leads, what would it be?”
  • “Is there anything else you’d like to share about your experience on this team?”

The combination of specific and open-ended questions gives you both measurable data and the qualitative context to understand it.

Manager effectiveness survey in the OnSurvey designer
Manager effectiveness survey in the OnSurvey designer.

Step 2: Define trigger conditions and scheduling

A survey that arrives at the wrong time gets ignored — or worse, gets resentful compliance. OnSurvey lets you define trigger conditions so surveys are sent when they’re most relevant.

  • A new manager completes their first 90 days in role
  • A team restructuring is finalized in Workday
  • A manager’s team exceeds a certain size threshold
  • A new hire completes their onboarding period
  • Quarterly pulse surveys for all managers
  • Annual comprehensive surveys aligned with development planning cycles
  • Mid-year check-ins for managers in development programs
  • Only survey teams with a minimum number of direct reports (to protect anonymity)
  • Skip managers who are on leave or in transition
  • Adjust frequency based on manager tenure or previous scores

The key is matching the survey to the moment.

OnSurvey schedule settings for a recurring manager effectiveness survey
OnSurvey schedule settings for a recurring manager effectiveness survey.

Step 3: Receiving and monitoring responses

Once your survey is live, OnSurvey provides real-time visibility into response rates and completion status — directly within Workday.

What to monitor

  • Overall response rate by team, department, and location
  • Completion rate versus partial responses (partial responses may indicate survey fatigue or question confusion)
  • Response velocity — are people responding quickly or letting the survey sit?

Nudging without nagging

OnSurvey supports automated reminders that you can customize in tone and timing. A gentle reminder at the halfway mark and a final nudge before close is usually sufficient. Resist the urge to send daily reminders — it undermines the voluntary nature of the process.

Manager effectiveness survey results dashboard in OnSurvey
Manager effectiveness survey results dashboard in OnSurvey.

Step 4: Secure sharing of survey responses in Workday

This is where trust is either built or broken. How you share results determines whether the next survey will get honest responses or safe ones.

Anonymity and aggregation

OnSurvey enforces configurable anonymity thresholds. If a manager’s team has fewer than the minimum respondent threshold (typically five), individual results are suppressed and rolled up to the next level. Open-ended responses are presented without identifying metadata.

Who sees what

  • The manager receives an aggregated summary of their team’s feedback — scores, themes from open-ended responses, and comparison to organizational benchmarks. They do not see individual responses.
  • The manager’s manager receives the same summary, with the ability to compare across their direct reports.
  • HR / People Partners receive cross-organizational views to identify systemic patterns, outlier teams, and development priorities.
  • Employees receive acknowledgment that results have been reviewed and a summary of organizational themes — closing the loop.
OnSurvey response security domains for sharing survey responses securely in Workday
OnSurvey response security domains for survey results.

Ask the right questions and make it frictionless to answer

Manager effectiveness surveys aren’t really about surveys. They’re about whether your organization is willing to ask honest questions about leadership — and then do something with the answers.

The companies that get this right don’t just have better managers. They have stronger cultures, lower attrition, faster leadership pipelines, and teams that genuinely want to do great work. The companies that don’t get it right — or don’t try at all — keep wondering why their engagement scores are flat and their best people keep leaving.

So here's the question: what would change in your organization if every manager received thoughtful, specific, actionable feedback — and was supported in acting on it?

If you’re ready to find out, OnSurvey makes it possible — natively in Workday, designed for trust, and built for organizations that take leadership seriously.

Try OnSurvey

Start your pilot and see how manager effectiveness feedback can transform your leadership culture.

FAQ

A short, behavior-specific survey completed by a manager’s direct reports about how that manager communicates, gives feedback, handles conflict and supports growth. It measures leadership as experienced by the team, which performance reviews and engagement surveys do not capture.

Engagement surveys measure how employees feel about the organization; 360 reviews collect broad, often annual feedback for one person. Manager effectiveness surveys are focused, repeatable and tied to moments such as a new manager’s first 90 days or a reorganization.

OnSurvey enforces configurable anonymity thresholds (no results for teams below a minimum size), aggregates responses before a manager sees them, and stores everything in Workday under its security domains, so the audience for each result is enforced by the system rather than by policy.

Aim for 70% or higher. Below 50% the results reflect the most and least satisfied voices rather than the team, so use automated reminders and keep the survey short.

Yes. OnSurvey can send it when a new manager completes 90 days in role, when a restructuring is finalized in Workday, when a team crosses a size threshold, or on a quarterly or annual cadence, with conditional rules to skip managers on leave or in transition.

On this page

Surveys built on Workday

OnSurvey runs manager effectiveness surveys natively in Workday: event triggers, anonymity thresholds and results under Workday security. Request a demo.

Try OnSurvey from the Workday Marketplace

If you are ready to find out what would change when every manager gets specific, actionable feedback, OnSurvey on the Workday Marketplace makes it possible natively in Workday. Request a demo or read more on the OnSurvey page.

With manager effectiveness surveys in OnSurvey, you get: